I watched Robert F. Kennedy Jr. stand in front of a room full of Republicans this week and say something nobody would’ve predicted a decade ago: that his father and his uncle “would not recognize the Democratic Party of today.” He said it at the Republican National Committee’s first-ever midterm convention, held in Dallas, and the crowd roared as if he’d just landed a punch line. In a sense, he had.
Read more Those Who Walk Away from Effective Altruism
That one sentence tells you where our politics stands in September of 2026. The party of Franklin Roosevelt and Jack Kennedy has narrowed itself down to a handful of mandatory positions, and even a Kennedy can’t squeeze in anymore. Meanwhile, the party supposedly reserved for the country club crowd is the one whose governing coalition now includes a former Soros hedge fund executive, a Teamster’s daughter, and a one-time Hawaii congresswoman who ran for president as a Democrat. That’s not a party lineup. That’s a family reunion where half the cousins used to hate each other, and now they’re doing the electric slide together.
Understand what that convention actually was. Republicans had never held a midterm convention before in the party’s history, and they used it to roll out a populist economic pitch, including a proposed $5,000 dividend check for American households, aimed squarely at the union households and working-class voters that Democrats used to consider their own turf. You don’t build a program like that to please the country-club wing. You build it to keep pulling people out of the other party’s base.
Call it what it is. The Republican Party has become the big tent. The Democratic Party has become the circus, and not the fun kind with elephants. The kind where every act has to land the same trick exactly the same way every single night, or the ringmaster cuts you loose.
Start with the headliner. RFK Jr. didn’t tiptoe around it in Dallas. He told the crowd Democrats had become defined by “blind hatred” of Donald Trump, and he spent a chunk of his half hour walking through what he called the party’s wartime abandonment, COVID being the war, of free speech, religious liberty, due process, and medical autonomy. I’ve followed the man for years and don’t agree with him on everything. But his argument lands because it isn’t partisan spin. It’s a man watching his own family’s coalition trade “question authority” for “trust the science, citizen,” and deciding he’d rather stand somewhere that still argues with the government than take dictation from it.
Then look at who’s actually running the government’s business. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent spent more than two decades as a top lieutenant at Soros Fund Management, helped George Soros make a billion dollars breaking the Bank of England, and wrote checks to Al Gore, John Kerry, Hillary Clinton, and Barack Obama long before he ever wrote one to Trump. He runs the U.S. Treasury today, not a hedge fund desk in London. Former Labor Secretary Lori Chavez-DeRemer is the daughter of a Teamster who co-sponsored a union bill so aggressive it made half the Republican conference wince, and the Senate confirmed her with seventeen Democratic votes because organized labor asked for her by name. For a year and a half, the president’s own director of national intelligence was Tulsi Gabbard, a four-term Democratic congresswoman and former Democratic presidential candidate, until she announced her resignation in May, citing her husband’s cancer diagnosis. And Trump spent roughly eight years as a registered Democrat in the 2000s, writing checks to the very people he now beats in elections. The traffic runs both directions, too: Pennsylvania’s own Democratic senator, John Fetterman, popped up by video during the Dallas program to praise Republican Senate candidate Dave McCormick, a courtesy no sitting Democrat would have extended a decade ago. Add it up, and you get a governing coalition built in part out of people the Democratic Party used to call its own.
This isn’t a party demanding ideological purity at the door. It’s a party that opened the flap and said, “Come on in! We’ll sort the seating chart later.”
Read more DOJ Charges 16 in Illegal Voting Cases as Election Enforcement Expands
To be fair, a big tent has its own headaches. I’ve watched Republicans go at each other over tariffs, over Ukraine, and over spending—hard enough to make a family Thanksgiving look tame by comparison. A coalition this wide doesn’t move in lockstep, and it shouldn’t pretend to. Anyone who tells you the modern GOP is a monolith hasn’t sat through a primary. Reagan understood the trade-off better than anyone; his eleventh commandment, “thou shalt not speak ill of a fellow Republican,” was built for exactly this kind of noisy, disagreeable coalition. He’d rather have the argument inside the tent than lose the voter outside it.
The Democratic Party made the opposite bet. It’s spent the last several years primarying its own moderates, running litmus tests on gender ideology and border policy that shift every eighteen months, and treating disagreement as evidence of moral failure rather than a normal feature of a governing coalition. There’s a real difference between a party arguing about direction and a party that cancels its own candidates for failing a test nobody wrote down. One of those is a family dinner. The other is a struggle session, and I’ve spent enough time around actual struggle to know the difference. A party that eats its own comedians for old jokes and its own biologists for stating a chromosome count isn’t enforcing values. It’s enforcing fear, and fear is a lousy long-term recruiting strategy.
I grew up on Reagan’s Republican Party in the 1980s and moved to California in 1990 when the state still had two functioning parties and a governor who could win a real landslide, and I’ve spent the 36 years since then watching my adopted state turn into a one-party laboratory for every wacky idea Sacramento can dream up. I’ve coached kids from every background you can imagine, on football fields and rugby pitches from Kern County to San Diego, and not one of those parents ever asked me for a loyalty oath before letting their son play on my team. Nobody checked a voter registration card before a kid got handed a mouthguard. Political parties used to work the same way, recruiting talent wherever they found it and worrying about ideological alignment later. Then one of the two parties decided loyalty oaths were the whole point, and it’s been shedding members like Kennedy ever since.
The circus used to be the greatest show on earth. Then it stopped adapting, the crowds thinned, and the whole operation eventually folded the tent for good. Political coalitions aren’t exempt from that math. One that keeps recruiting former Democrats, former Soros lieutenants, and Teamsters’ daughters isn’t winning by accident. It’s winning because it’s the only tent left with room to grow.
Democrats have a choice heading into this year’s midterms: widen the tent or keep running the circus. Judging by what came out of Dallas this week, one party already made its call. The other one is still arguing backstage about who gets to wear the big shoes.
Read more Trump Announces ‘AI Force,’ Plans to Name AI Czar as U.S. Pushes Tech Dominance
